Federal Court Rules USCIS Immigration Holds Unlawful for 39 Countries
If your USCIS case has been stuck in limbo, broad USCIS immigration holds can leave you unsure when you’ll get a decision. This guide explains a recent federal court ruling and what it says about the Administrative Procedure Act, including how it may affect green card delays, work permits, asylum, or naturalization cases. ReferU.AI can connect you with an immigration attorney who can review your facts and help you decide the best next step.
Flat vector illustration of a federal court stopping USCIS immigration holds, with applicants and released case files representing unlawful holds affecting 39 countries.
Images
Videos
Publish Date (Social)
Scheduled (Social)
Scheduled (Social)
Images Posted (Social)
Images Posted (Social)
Videos Posted (Social)
Videos Posted (Social)
Featured
Created time
May 13, 2026 12:08 PM
Sub-item
Authors
CTA Practice Area (Social)
TikTok Failed (Social)
Videos Post Links (Social)
TikTok Post Links (Social)
Images Post IDs (Social)
YT Post ID
Video Pending Manual (Social)
TikTok Posted (Social)
TikTok Post IDs (Social)
Video Cover (Social)
Images Post Links (Social)
First Comment (Social)
Videos Failed (Social)
Videos Failed (Social)
YT Embedded
Images Delete (Social)
Videos Delete (Social)
Carousel Video URL (Social)
A federal judge in Boston handed down a significant immigration ruling on April 30, 2026, finding that U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services used unlawful blanket holds to freeze immigration benefits for people tied to 39 designated countries. In the preliminary injunction in Akmurat O. Doe et al. v. Donald J. Trump et al., U.S. District Judge Julia E. Kobick said the agency’s adjudicative-hold policy was likely contrary to law and arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act.
The ruling also addressed a USCIS policy treating nationality as a “significant negative factor” in certain discretionary decisions. According to Reuters, the court blocked enforcement of both policies for 22 plaintiffs who submitted sworn declarations of harm, while directing the parties to address whether broader relief may extend to others in the roughly 200-person case. A recent case summary describing the April 30 order likewise reports that the lawsuit involves about 200 individuals.
What The Court Actually Ruled
Judge Kobick’s order did not erase every screening measure used by USCIS, and it did not automatically grant immigration benefits. Instead, it targeted the adjudicative hold policy set out in PM 602-0192 and PM 602-0194, which paused final decisions on certain pending applications.
The court described the challenged system as an indefinite hold on applications submitted by people from countries named in presidential proclamations, along with a separate hold affecting asylum applications. The opinion explains that these policies prevented USCIS from issuing final decisions even while cases continued moving through internal processing. In practical terms, that often left applicants in a prolonged state of uncertainty over green cards, work permits, naturalization, and asylum-related matters under the agency memoranda challenged in the lawsuit.
The litigation sits at the intersection of immigration processing, executive power, and administrative law. The government argued that the policies were connected to national-security concerns and to presidential proclamations restricting or limiting entry for nationals of certain countries. But the court drew a distinction between entry restrictions and domestic adjudication of benefits for people already in the United States in the memorandum and order issued on April 30, 2026.
That distinction matters. Entry bans and visa restrictions often receive substantial deference from courts. Domestic processing decisions by USCIS, however, can be evaluated under ordinary administrative-law principles, including whether an agency acted consistently with governing statutes and regulations. Here, the judge concluded the government had not adequately explained why findings about vetting and screening for entry justified a sweeping pause on domestic benefit adjudications for people tied to 39 countries.
For non-lawyers, the phrase “arbitrary and capricious” often sounds abstract. In general terms, it refers to agency action that lacks a reasoned explanation, ignores important parts of the problem, or departs from the law or the agency’s own rules without sufficient justification. That is one reason APA challenges often become central in cases involving abrupt policy changes.
The Scope Of Relief Was Important
One detail in the ruling may catch many readers by surprise: the injunction did not immediately cover every person potentially affected by the hold policy. The court ordered USCIS to lift the holds only for the 22 plaintiffs who submitted declarations showing likely irreparable harm. It also barred the agency from applying the negative-factor policy to those same individuals’ pending adjustment and work-authorization applications.
At the same time, the opinion repeatedly notes that the case involves approximately 200 plaintiffs from 20 countries, and the judge directed the parties to confer about whether comparable relief may be warranted for others. That narrower procedural posture is important because public summaries of the ruling can sometimes make it sound broader than the immediate injunction actually was.
Even so, the legal reasoning may carry weight well beyond those 22 people. According to Reuters, counsel for the plaintiffs characterized the decision as one of the first to address both the adjudicative hold and the nationality-based negative factor together in the same ruling, which may influence future challenges involving similar USCIS practices and the same agency policies adopted in late 2025 and early 2026.
What It May Mean For Immigrants And Families
For immigrants with pending USCIS cases, the opinion may signal that courts remain willing to scrutinize broad freezes that are not clearly rooted in statute or regulation. It may also matter for families whose immigration plans were disrupted by indefinite delay rather than outright denial. In many cases, uncertainty can be as damaging as a denial because it affects employment, travel, school, medical planning, and long-term family stability.
For employers and universities, the order may also carry practical consequences. Work authorization delays can interrupt hiring, onboarding, and retention. Family-based and employment-based adjustment applications can stall career moves, relocation plans, and dependent status issues. In that sense, this is not only an immigration-policy story. It is also a labor, education, and family-security story.
What Affected Parties May Want To Consider
People with pending USCIS applications who believe they were placed on an adjudicative hold may want to consider gathering copies of receipt notices, requests for evidence, prior agency communications, and any indication that a case has been frozen without a final decision. In matters involving delayed green cards, work permits, asylum, or naturalization, an attorney might help determine whether the delay reflects ordinary processing, extra vetting, or a broader policy issue like the challenged USCIS memoranda and policy alert.
This ruling also highlights how much immigration cases can turn on documented harm. The 22 plaintiffs who obtained immediate injunctive relief were the ones who filed declarations explaining concrete hardship. Some people in similar situations may want to discuss with counsel whether declarations, mandamus claims, APA claims, or class-based strategies fit the facts of their cases.
The larger takeaway is that delays are not always just delays. Sometimes they trace back to a formal agency policy, and when that happens, a case may involve more than routine follow-up with USCIS. It may involve a legal challenge to the policy itself.
The Bigger Picture
This Boston injunction arrives at a moment when courts are continuing to define the outer limits of executive immigration authority. The government still has room to defend its policies as the case moves forward, and appeals remain possible. But for now, the April 30 preliminary injunction stands as a notable reminder that even in immigration matters, agencies may be required to tie major policy choices to actual statutory authority, consistent regulations, and reasoned decision-making.
For people whose applications have been stuck in limbo, that may be the most important development of all: a federal court has signaled that an indefinite, nationality-linked freeze on domestic immigration adjudications may not survive ordinary judicial review.
Visit ReferU.AI to get matched with an attorney who has demonstrable experience in cases like yours — for free.