Ninth Circuit Upholds Refusal to Enforce Arbitration Agreement in Class Action

If your employer introduces a new arbitration agreement while you’re part of an employment class action, it can be confusing to know what rights you still have and what deadlines matter. This guide explains how courts may evaluate an arbitration agreement rollout under Rule 23(d), including issues that come up in wage-and-hour and other employment disputes. ReferU.AI can help you find an attorney with experience in arbitration and class action litigation by analyzing billions of court records.

Ninth Circuit Upholds Refusal to Enforce Arbitration Agreement in Class Action
Type
Child
Status
Approved
Title (YouTube)
Images Failed (Social)
Do not index
Publish Date (TikTok)
Videos Post IDs (Social)
Hashtags (Social)
Caption
Caption X
Cover
ninth-circuit-arbitration-agreement-class-action.png
OG Image
ninth-circuit-arbitration-agreement-class-action.png
Alt Image Text
Flat vector illustration of a Ninth Circuit arbitration agreement dispute in a class action, with a courthouse, judge’s gavel, workers, and a blocked arbitration document.
Images
1.png2.png3.png4.png
Videos
Template - HD 720p.mov
Publish Date (Social)
Scheduled (Social)
Scheduled (Social)
Images Posted (Social)
Images Posted (Social)
Videos Posted (Social)
Videos Posted (Social)
Featured
Created time
May 7, 2026 01:58 PM
Sub-item
Authors
CTA Practice Area (Social)
TikTok Failed (Social)
Videos Post Links (Social)
TikTok Post Links (Social)
Images Post IDs (Social)
YT Post ID
Video Pending Manual (Social)
TikTok Posted (Social)
TikTok Post IDs (Social)
Video Cover (Social)
Images Post Links (Social)
First Comment (Social)
Videos Failed (Social)
YT Embedded
Images Delete (Social)
Videos Delete (Social)
Carousel Video URL (Social)
A new Ninth Circuit decision is drawing attention across employment and class action litigation after the court affirmed a district judge’s refusal to enforce an arbitration agreement rolled out during an active wage-and-hour class case. In Avery v. TEKsystems, Inc., the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held on January 28, 2026 that the district court acted within its authority under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(d) when it declined to enforce the agreement because the surrounding communications to class members were misleading. According to National Law Review, the ruling highlights a meaningful limit on arbitration enforcement when a defendant’s conduct interferes with the fairness of the class process. The Ninth Circuit’s published opinion lays out that holding in detail.
The dispute grew out of a California wage-and-hour class action filed on January 28, 2022, in which current and former recruiters alleged they had been misclassified as exempt employees and denied overtime and meal-and-rest-break protections. The Ninth Circuit said TEKsystems introduced a new mandatory arbitration agreement on December 19, 2023, after class-certification briefing had closed, and then moved to compel arbitration on June 10, 2024, just days before the class notice period ended, based on the timeline described in the appellate opinion.

Background On Why This Case Matters

Arbitration agreements are common in employment disputes, and federal law often treats them as enforceable contracts. In general terms, employers may ask workers to resolve disputes in individual arbitration rather than in court, and those agreements frequently include class-action waivers. That broader framework comes from Section 2 of the Federal Arbitration Act, which states that written arbitration agreements are generally “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable,” subject to recognized contract defenses.
Class actions work differently. Under Rule 23, once a class is certified, members are typically included unless they opt out. That structure is central to how notice, participation, and collective relief operate in federal class litigation. The Ninth Circuit emphasized that district courts have broad supervisory authority over class proceedings and class communications under Rule 23’s case-management provisions, especially where communications may distort the opt-out process or create confusion for absent class members.
That tension—between the FAA’s strong policy favoring arbitration and Rule 23’s protections for the integrity of class actions—sat at the center of Avery. The appellate panel concluded that a district court may, in an appropriate case, refuse enforcement of an arbitration agreement under Rule 23(d) where the agreement was procured through communications that threatened the fairness of the class process, as reflected in the court’s discussion of Rule 23(d) authority.

What The Ninth Circuit Actually Held

The Ninth Circuit did not announce a blanket rule against arbitration agreements in pending class cases. Instead, the panel focused on the way TEKsystems presented the agreement to putative class members. The court said the district judge found the rollout communications misleading because they included inconsistent statements about how and when employees could opt out, suggested class members would need to consult their own lawyers at their own expense rather than class counsel, and effectively altered the normal Rule 23 framework. Those findings appear in the Ninth Circuit’s description of the communications.
One of the court’s most notable observations was that TEKsystems had effectively tried to transform a Rule 23 opt-out proceeding into something closer to an opt-in process. In a class action, individuals usually remain part of the case unless they exclude themselves. Under TEKsystems’ arbitration rollout, the practical effect was different: if workers did nothing, they could lose participation in the class and be routed into arbitration instead. The panel treated that as a direct threat to the fairness of class administration, based on the court’s explanation of how the agreement changed the opt-out structure.
The court also rejected the argument that the arbitration agreement’s delegation clause required the arbitrator—not the district judge—to decide enforceability. Here, the panel held that the district court could decide whether Rule 23(d) barred enforcement in these circumstances, as discussed in the section addressing the delegation provision.

The Legal Framework Behind The Decision

The opinion relies heavily on the Supreme Court’s view that trial judges carry broad responsibility to protect absent class members and the integrity of the class-action process. The Ninth Circuit cited Gulf Oil Co. v. Bernard for the principle that district courts have both the duty and the authority to control communications in class cases where abuse or confusion could affect fairness. It also leaned on Hoffmann-La Roche Inc. v. Sperling for the related idea that courts have a substantial interest in supervising communications in aggregate litigation.
The panel further connected its reasoning to a more recent Ninth Circuit case, Dominguez v. Better Mortgage Corp., where restrictions on misleading and coercive communications with class members were upheld. In Avery, the court essentially extended that logic: if a district court may limit improper communications before an agreement is formed, it may also decline to enforce an agreement obtained through communications that undermine the Rule 23 process.
According to National Law Review, the decision places the Ninth Circuit alongside other appellate courts that have recognized a district court’s authority to police arbitration-related communications in class or collective proceedings. The Ninth Circuit itself stated that its holding is consistent with the circuits identified in the opinion, including the Fourth, Sixth, and Eleventh Circuits.

What This May Mean For Employers And Workers

For employers, the case is a reminder that timing and messaging can matter as much as the text of the arbitration agreement itself. Rolling out a new arbitration program in the middle of active class litigation may attract close judicial scrutiny, especially where communications to current employees overlap with a live class notice period, minimize the role of class counsel, or create confusion about how workers can preserve their rights. Some companies in similar situations may look at Avery as a warning that arbitration agreements introduced during pending class litigation are not automatically insulated from Rule 23 review, particularly where the communications threaten the fairness of the proceedings.
For workers and putative class members, the ruling may be especially relevant where an employer sends out new dispute-resolution paperwork after a lawsuit is already underway. In general terms, that kind of communication can raise questions about whether employees were clearly informed, whether they understood what rights were affected, and whether the employer’s process was consistent with the structure of the class action already pending in court.
The case may also matter beyond wage-and-hour disputes. Any class litigation involving late-stage arbitration rollouts, revised dispute-resolution policies, or internal communications directed at absent class members could prompt similar fights over fairness, coercion, and enforceability.

What Affected Parties Might Consider

People dealing with an employment class action, or with a newly presented arbitration agreement after litigation has already started, may want to consider how the communication was framed, what deadlines were disclosed, and whether the agreement changed participation rights in a pending case. An attorney might help evaluate whether the rollout resembled the kind of misleading or one-sided process the Ninth Circuit examined in Avery.
For employers facing class claims, this decision may influence how internal notices, opt-out procedures, and arbitration programs are structured when litigation is already active. For employees, it may affect whether a newly signed or automatically applied arbitration agreement is truly enforceable in the context of an ongoing class action. In either direction, the case suggests that courts may look beyond the contract’s text and examine the broader circumstances in which the agreement was presented.
When a dispute involves arbitration, class notice, wage claims, or communications sent during pending litigation, early case assessment often turns on very specific facts and procedural timing. A lawyer with documented experience in highly similar matters may be able to identify whether a communication campaign, arbitration clause, or class-action notice issue creates additional leverage or defenses based on court records and case similarity.
Visit ReferU.AI to get matched with an attorney who has demonstrable experience in cases like yours — for free.