Ninth Circuit grants asylum-seekers’ petition in Menjivar-Ayala v. Blanche

The Ninth Circuit granted the petition in Menjivar-Ayala v. Blanche and sent the case back to the BIA after finding an abuse of discretion. The ruling highlights how attorney communication failures and missed appellate deadlines may affect due process in removal proceedings.

Ninth Circuit grants asylum-seekers’ petition in Menjivar-Ayala v. Blanche
Type
Child
Status
Approved
Title (YouTube)
Images Failed (Social)
Do not index
Publish Date (TikTok)
Videos Post IDs (Social)
Hashtags (Social)
Caption
Caption X
Cover
menjivar-ayala-v-blanche-asylum-seekers-ninth-circuit.png
OG Image
menjivar-ayala-v-blanche-asylum-seekers-ninth-circuit.png
Alt Image Text
Flat vector illustration for Menjivar-Ayala v. Blanche showing asylum-seekers and a family of three approaching a reopened appellate path beside a courthouse, symbolizing the Ninth Circuit granting review after a missed filing deadline.
Images
Videos
Publish Date (Social)
Scheduled (Social)
Images Posted (Social)
Videos Posted (Social)
Featured
Created time
Jul 9, 2026 09:41 PM
Sub-item
Authors
CTA Practice Area (Social)
TikTok Failed (Social)
Videos Post Links (Social)
TikTok Post Links (Social)
Images Post IDs (Social)
YT Post ID
Video Pending Manual (Social)
TikTok Posted (Social)
TikTok Post IDs (Social)
Video Cover (Social)
Images Post Links (Social)
First Comment (Social)
Videos Failed (Social)
YT Embedded
Images Delete (Social)
Videos Delete (Social)
Carousel Video URL (Social)
On July 9, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued a published opinion in Menjivar-Ayala v. Blanche, granting a petition for review filed by Carlos Menjivar-Ayala, Maria Ramirez-Chicas, and their son. The panel vacated the Board of Immigration Appeals’ denial of reopening and remanded the case for further proceedings after concluding that the agency abused its discretion. The decision also appears on the Ninth Circuit’s July 9, 2026 opinions list and in the federal appellate case record for No. 24-4562.
At bottom, the case turned on a familiar but high-stakes problem in immigration court: what happens when a noncitizen loses the chance to seek judicial review because prior counsel failed to communicate a Board decision and the filing deadline. In general terms, the Ninth Circuit’s answer was that the Board could not brush that problem aside simply because the family also received a courtesy copy in the mail. For represented noncitizens, reliance on counsel is often part of the process itself, and the court treated that reliance as reasonable. The panel’s discussion of the missed December 19, 2023 Board decision and the lost 30-day petition deadline framed the dispute.

Background For Non-Lawyers

The petitioners are described in the Ninth Circuit’s opinion as natives and citizens of Honduras who entered the United States in 2021 and sought asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture based on violent threats against their family. An immigration judge denied those claims, and on December 19, 2023, the Board of Immigration Appeals affirmed that denial. The problem came next: the family’s attorney did not alert them to the Board’s decision until March 5, 2024, after the deadline to petition the Ninth Circuit had already passed. According to the opinion’s factual summary of prior counsel’s withdrawal and acknowledgment of error, counsel accepted responsibility for the mistake and withdrew.
The family then retained new counsel and asked the Board to reopen proceedings and reissue its earlier decision so they could file a timely petition for review. That request matters because federal appellate deadlines in immigration cases can be unforgiving. If a person misses the filing window, a merits challenge to the removal order may never get heard.
The Board denied reopening on two grounds. First, it took the position that it lacked authority to consider ineffective assistance tied to a missed petition-for-review deadline in the Ninth Circuit because that conduct concerned a different tribunal. Second, it concluded that the family had enough notice because a courtesy copy of the Board’s decision mailed to their address identified the 30-day deadline.

Why The Ninth Circuit Reversed

The Ninth Circuit rejected both rationales.
On the first point, the panel relied on its 2025 precedent in Li v. Bondi, which held that the Board may consider ineffective-assistance claims even when the attorney’s deficient conduct affected a filing in the court of appeals rather than the agency itself. In other words, the Board could not sidestep the reopening request by saying the lawyer’s error happened “after” Board proceedings ended. The panel held that counsel’s failure to notify the family of the Board decision and the court deadline was “grounds to seek reopening before the BIA,” as stated in the court’s analysis of the Board’s authority to review the claim.
On the second point, the court held that service of a courtesy copy of the Board’s decision did not rebut the presumption of prejudice caused by counsel’s deficient performance. The opinion emphasized that represented noncitizens commonly rely on their attorneys to explain what a Board decision means, whether it is adverse, what the deadline is, and what happens if that deadline is missed. The panel wrote that it was unreasonable to expect the petitioners to understand the Board’s decision and decipher the 30-day filing deadline on their own.
That part of the ruling may resonate far beyond this family’s case. Immigration procedure is technical even for English speakers with legal training. For families navigating removal proceedings, often in a second language and under severe time pressure, “notice” on paper and meaningful notice in practice are not always the same thing. The Ninth Circuit’s analysis suggests that when counsel is already retained, the legal system may have to account for how representation actually works, not just whether an envelope arrived.

The Legal Framework Behind The Decision

Motions to reopen are often described as disfavored, but the Ninth Circuit repeated that they serve as a “critical safety valve” in the asylum process. That concept matters because reopening is often the only realistic way to repair a case after a serious attorney error.
The court also applied the familiar ineffective-assistance framework used in immigration proceedings: deficient performance plus prejudice. Under the panel’s summary of the prejudice standard from Salazar-Gonzalez v. Lynch, when a lawyer’s error causes a noncitizen to lose the right to appeal altogether, prejudice is presumed. That presumption was central here. The family did not merely lose a tactical advantage; they lost access to appellate review of the underlying asylum denial.
The opinion also leaned on earlier Ninth Circuit reasoning in Iturribarria v. INS and related cases, which recognize that represented noncitizens understandably rely on retained counsel to guide them through complicated immigration proceedings. That principle may sound basic, but in removal cases it can determine whether an error is treated as harmless paperwork or as a constitutional-level fairness problem.

What This May Mean For Immigrants And Their Families

For immigrants in removal proceedings, the practical significance of Menjivar-Ayala may be substantial. The decision reinforces the idea that attorney breakdowns near the end of a case can still justify reopening, even when the missed step is a petition for review in federal court rather than a filing before the Board. It also signals that agencies may face closer scrutiny when they rely on formal notice alone to deny relief after counsel error. Those themes are reflected throughout the published appellate decision remanding the case to the Board.
For immigration attorneys and immigration judges, the opinion may influence how future reopening motions are framed and evaluated. Lawyers handling post-decision communications may view the case as a reminder that deadline failures can carry consequences beyond malpractice exposure; they can also upend the finality of agency decisions. Judges and Board members may read the ruling as another data point that sudden representation failures cannot always be cured by pointing to boilerplate notices or mailed copies.
For families already dealing with representation disruptions, the case may offer a clearer roadmap for arguing that a missed deadline was not their fault. Of course, every record is different. Issues such as proof of notice, affidavits, language access, diligence, and procedural posture can all shape the outcome. An attorney might help determine whether a late-stage error fits into the same line of cases as Menjivar-Ayala and Li.

What Affected Parties Might Consider

People facing removal proceedings sometimes assume that once a filing deadline passes, the case is simply over. This ruling suggests the picture can be more nuanced, particularly where the missed deadline traces back to documented attorney error. Some people in similar situations may want to consider preserving records of communications with prior counsel, copies of mailed decisions, withdrawal notices, and timelines showing when they first learned of an adverse ruling.
The broader lesson is less about one family’s case and more about legal fit. Immigration cases involving ineffective assistance, reopening requests, and federal appellate deadlines can become intensely procedural very quickly. In matters like that, experience with highly-similar cases may matter as much as familiarity with asylum law itself. A lawyer with documented experience handling missed-deadline reopening motions, Board practice, and Ninth Circuit petitions may be better positioned to evaluate what options remain based on the actual record.
Visit ReferU.AI to get matched with an attorney who has demonstrable experience in cases like yours — for free.