Supreme Court Clarifies ERISA Withdrawal Liability Calculation Rules for Multiemployer Pension Plans

Worried that an ERISA withdrawal liability bill could change because pension-plan assumptions shift after the key valuation date? This guide explains the Supreme Court’s 9–0 decision letting multiemployer pension plans adopt actuarial assumptions after the measurement date, as long as they’re still reasonable, so you’ll understand what it may mean for employers and plan trustees. ReferU.AI can help you find an attorney with ERISA withdrawal liability experience to evaluate your risk and next steps.

Supreme Court Clarifies ERISA Withdrawal Liability Calculation Rules for Multiemployer Pension Plans
Type
Child
Status
Approved
Title (YouTube)
Images Failed (Social)
Do not index
Publish Date (TikTok)
Videos Post IDs (Social)
Hashtags (Social)
Caption
Caption X
Cover
erisa-withdrawal-liability-multiemployer-pension-plans.png
OG Image
erisa-withdrawal-liability-multiemployer-pension-plans.png
Alt Image Text
Flat vector illustration of Supreme Court ERISA withdrawal liability calculation for multiemployer pension plans, showing legal and actuarial timing concepts with employers, trustees, workers, and a shared pension fund.
Images
1.png2.png3.png4.png
Videos
Template - HD 720p.mov
Publish Date (Social)
Scheduled (Social)
Scheduled (Social)
Images Posted (Social)
Images Posted (Social)
Videos Posted (Social)
Videos Posted (Social)
Featured
Created time
May 22, 2026 03:28 PM
Sub-item
Authors
CTA Practice Area (Social)
TikTok Failed (Social)
Videos Post Links (Social)
TikTok Post Links (Social)
Images Post IDs (Social)
YT Post ID
Video Pending Manual (Social)
TikTok Posted (Social)
TikTok Post IDs (Social)
Video Cover (Social)
Images Post Links (Social)
First Comment (Social)
Videos Failed (Social)
Videos Failed (Social)
YT Embedded
Images Delete (Social)
Videos Delete (Social)
Carousel Video URL (Social)
In a unanimous decision issued on May 21, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that ERISA does not require multiemployer pension plans to lock in actuarial assumptions before the statutory measurement date when calculating withdrawal liability. In M & K Employee Solutions, LLC v. Trustees of IAM National Pension Fund, Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson wrote for a 9-0 Court that actuaries may adopt assumptions after that date, so long as those assumptions remain reasonable and reflect the actuary’s best estimate of the plan’s anticipated experience.
The ruling resolves a split between the D.C. Circuit and the Second Circuit over a technical but financially significant question: when an actuary may select the assumptions used to calculate what a departing employer owes an underfunded multiemployer pension plan. For employers, unions, trustees, and plan professionals, the decision may reshape how exit liability disputes are argued and valued in the months ahead.

Background On Withdrawal Liability

Multiemployer pension plans are jointly maintained by multiple employers, typically under collective bargaining agreements in industries like construction, trucking, hospitality, and manufacturing. When an employer leaves an underfunded plan, ERISA can require that employer to pay its allocated share of the plan’s unfunded vested benefits. That payment is known as withdrawal liability.
The underlying math is complicated. To estimate a plan’s future benefit obligations in present-value terms, actuaries use assumptions about items like interest rates, mortality, retirement timing, and other expected experience. Even modest changes in those assumptions can materially affect the amount a withdrawing employer is assessed.
The dispute in this case centered on whether ERISA required those assumptions to be selected on or before the measurement date tied to the withdrawal liability calculation. The employers argued that the statute’s timing language effectively imposed that deadline. The pension fund argued that the statute imposed standards for the quality of assumptions, not a rigid deadline for when they had to be adopted.
The Supreme Court agreed with the fund. In its opinion interpreting ERISA sections 1391 and 1393, the Court held that the statute requires assumptions to be reasonable, to take account of the plan’s experience and reasonable expectations, and to offer the actuary’s best estimate of anticipated experience under the plan, but it does not add a textual cutoff requiring those assumptions to be chosen before the measurement date.

What The Court Actually Said

The Court’s reasoning turned largely on statutory text. Section 1391 governs methods for calculating withdrawal liability, while Section 1393 governs the actuarial assumptions used in that process. According to the Court, the phrase “as of” in Section 1391 fixes the date for the underlying plan data used in the calculation, but it does not create a separate deadline for selecting actuarial assumptions.
That distinction mattered. The Court described actuarial assumptions not as historical facts that exist in fixed form on a single day, but as predictive judgments that help translate plan data into a present-value estimate. In that framework, an actuary may review information that becomes available after the measurement date, so long as the assumptions ultimately reflect conditions and anticipated experience tied to that date.
The opinion also pointed to ERISA’s express language requiring assumptions to be “reasonable” and to offer the actuary’s “best estimate of anticipated experience under the plan”. Because Congress included specific timing language elsewhere in ERISA but not in Section 1393, the Court said it would not read an extra timing restriction into the statute.
Just as important, the Court declined to decide a different question that had also hovered over the dispute: whether assumptions may rely on information that was not available as of the measurement date. The opinion leaves that issue for another day. That unresolved point may keep some litigation alive, especially in cases where employers argue that a plan relied on hindsight rather than updated knowledge about conditions that already existed.

Why This Case Matters Beyond One Pension Fund

This ruling is likely to matter well beyond the parties in M & K. According to PBGC, multiemployer pension plans cover about 11.1 million workers and retirees, and the federal multiemployer insurance program protects participants across roughly 1,305 private-sector multiemployer plans. That means even a technical ruling on actuarial timing can have ripple effects across a large segment of unionized and collectively bargained retirement coverage.
For pension plans and trustees, the decision offers more flexibility in preparing withdrawal liability assessments. In practical terms, actuaries may be able to use more current information to formulate assumptions, rather than being boxed into assumptions selected before the relevant date. Plans are likely to argue that this approach produces valuations that better reflect economic reality.
For employers, the ruling may raise concerns about predictability. One of the central employer arguments in these cases has been that withdrawal liability can already be hard to estimate before a business transaction, closure, or bargaining change. If assumptions may be selected later, the final number may become even harder to forecast in real time. That uncertainty can affect due diligence in asset sales, restructuring, labor negotiations, and controlled-group planning.
For workers and retirees, the case may be viewed through a different lens. Multiemployer plans depend on ongoing contributions and accurate funding assumptions. A rule allowing actuaries to make assumptions based on fuller information may be seen by some as a tool that helps plans more accurately allocate underfunding to withdrawing employers, rather than shifting more risk onto remaining employers and participants.

The Legal Framework Going Forward

The decision does not give plans unlimited freedom. The governing standard remains the same: actuarial assumptions and methods must be reasonable and must reflect the actuary’s best estimate. That leaves room for future fights over whether a specific discount rate, mortality table, or projection method crosses the line from reasonable estimation into aggressive valuation.
That may be where the next wave of litigation develops. Instead of arguing primarily about when an assumption was selected, employers may focus more heavily on whether the chosen assumption was substantively reasonable under ERISA and accepted actuarial practice. Arbitration, which remains the required forum for many withdrawal liability disputes, could become even more centered on expert testimony and actuarial records.
The Court’s opinion may also interact with broader disputes over discount rates in withdrawal liability calculations. Multiemployer plans and employers have spent years litigating questions about the use of blended rates and other methods that can materially increase or decrease a withdrawal assessment. This decision does not settle those debates, but it may give plans stronger footing when defending assumptions adopted after the valuation date.

What Affected Parties May Want To Consider

For employers participating in multiemployer plans, this decision may influence how withdrawal exposure is evaluated during mergers, asset sales, plant shutdowns, contribution declines, and contract negotiations. In general terms, one takeaway is that a preliminary estimate based only on assumptions known before the measurement date may not match the figure that is later assessed.
For plan fiduciaries and administrators, the opinion may reinforce the importance of documenting why particular assumptions were selected, what information informed them, and how those assumptions fit ERISA’s reasonableness standard. A well-developed record may matter if an assessment is challenged in arbitration or later reviewed in court.
For unions and employees, the ruling may be relevant in industries where employer exits create pressure on already underfunded plans. If a withdrawal assessment changes because of post-measurement-date assumption selection, disputes over funding responsibility may become more technical, but the practical stakes remain deeply human: retirement security, contribution stability, and the long-term health of the plan.
And for businesses already facing a withdrawal liability demand, this is often the kind of ruling that can alter how a dispute is framed from the outset. The timeline of assumption selection may no longer be the lead argument, but the reasonableness of the assumptions, the information used, the valuation method, and the employer’s controlled-group exposure may still leave substantial room for challenge. An attorney with documented experience in ERISA withdrawal liability matters may help identify what is actually in dispute and what evidence is likely to matter most.
Visit ReferU.AI to get matched with an attorney who has demonstrable experience in cases like yours — for free.